Low-Glycemic Diet: HbA1c Fell 0.3 Points Across 29 Trials

A low-glycemic diet explained with real numbers: what the glycemic index measures, GI values for common foods, what changes them, and what research shows for blood sugar and weight.

A low-glycemic diet favours carbohydrate foods that raise blood sugar slowly. The glycemic index (GI) ranks foods on a scale where pure glucose scores 100. Foods at 55 or below are classed as low GI, and foods at 70 or above as high GI (1).

The idea is well supported for blood sugar control, less so for weight, and it has a blind spot that most articles skip. A low GI score does not make a food healthy, and the GI of a food can change a lot depending on how it is processed and cooked. This guide gives you the actual numbers.

Key Takeaways

  • Low GI means 55 or less on the glucose scale; high GI means 70 or more (1).
  • In people with diabetes, low-GI diets lowered HbA1c by about 0.3 percentage points, with high certainty evidence (4).
  • Effects on weight are small, and larger only when dietary GI drops by 20 points or more (7).
  • Processing matters: rolled oat porridge scores 55, instant oat porridge 79 (1).
  • Low GI is not the same as healthy, and experts say it should be judged within an otherwise healthy diet (3).

What the Glycemic Index Measures

Bowls of chickpeas, kidney beans, buckwheat, red lentils and oats on a white surfaceSave
Photo: MART PRODUCTION / Pexels

GI describes how quickly the carbohydrate in a food raises blood glucose compared with pure glucose. An international expert consensus concluded that GI is a valid and reproducible way to classify carbohydrate foods for this purpose (3).

GI has an important limitation: it says nothing about how much carbohydrate a normal serving contains. That is what glycemic load (GL) adds. It is calculated as the available carbohydrate in a serving multiplied by the food’s GI, then divided by 100 (1).

GI Values for Common Foods

These values come from the International Tables of Glycemic Index, which compile tested values from published studies (1):

FoodGIBand
Soya beans16Low
Kidney beans24Low
Barley28Low
Chickpeas28Low
Lentils32Low
Apple, raw36Low
Skim milk37Low
Carrots, boiled39Low
Orange, raw43Low
Spaghetti, white49Low
Banana, raw51Low
Sweet corn52Low
Porridge, rolled oats55Low
Sweet potato, boiled63Medium
Brown rice, boiled68Medium
White rice, boiled73High
Whole wheat bread74High
White wheat bread75High
Watermelon, raw76High
Potato, boiled78High
Instant oat porridge79High
Cornflakes81High

A newer 2021 edition lists more than 4,000 foods. It confirms that dairy, legumes, pasta and fruit are usually low GI, while breads, breakfast cereals and rice come in high, medium and low versions depending on how they are made (2).

Five Numbers That Surprise People

You might expectThe tables showWhat it means
Whole wheat bread to be far lower than white breadWhole wheat bread 74, white bread 75Grinding grain into fine flour matters more than the colour of the loaf
Brown rice to be low GIBrown rice 68 (medium), white rice 73 (high)Brown rice is better, but not a low-GI food
All oats to behave the sameRolled oat porridge 55, instant oat porridge 79Processing can push the same grain from low to high
Watermelon to be a blood sugar problemWatermelon 76GI is high, but a normal serving contains little carbohydrate, which is where glycemic load helps
Chocolate to be high GIChocolate 40A low GI does not make a food healthy

What Pushes a Food’s GI Up or Down

  • Processing. The same grain can land in very different bands. Rolled oats and instant oats are the clearest example in the tables (1).
  • Grain variety and starch type. A systematic review of rice found GI values from 48 to 93, driven mainly by starch characteristics, parboiling, and cooking, storage and reheating (10). The review was written by Unilever researchers.
  • Milling. Cooked for the same time, brown rice gave a lower glucose response than white rice. With the longer cooking brown rice usually needs, the difference became smaller and less consistent (10).
  • Portion and carbohydrate amount. In type 2 diabetes, trials found that eating less carbohydrate in a meal or more soluble fiber both lowered after-meal glucose spikes — and the same swings are often blamed for mood dips, which we examine in sugar and mood (11).
  • Meal order. A narrative review suggests starting a meal with vegetables and protein and eating carbohydrates later can reduce the glucose response. That is a proposal built on smaller studies, not a settled finding (12).

What the Research Shows

QuestionWhat the evidence showsHow sure we are
Does it improve blood sugar in diabetes?A BMJ meta-analysis of 29 trial comparisons in 1,617 people with type 1 or 2 diabetes found HbA1c fell by 0.31 percentage points versus higher-GI diets, with smaller improvements in LDL cholesterol, body weight, blood pressure and CRP (4). An earlier analysis of 54 trials reached similar conclusions (5)High certainty for HbA1c, moderate for most other outcomes
Does it help with weight?Across 101 studies with 8,527 participants, low-GI diets produced small improvements in weight, BMI and cholesterol, and larger effects when the diet lowered GI by 20 points or more (7)Small effect; depends on sticking to it
Is a high-GI diet linked to disease?Pooled data from large cohorts of over 100,000 people linked high-GI diets with 27% higher type 2 diabetes risk, 15% higher cardiovascular risk and 8% higher all-cause mortality (8)Observational; an umbrella review rated this kind of evidence very low to low certainty
Is GI a valid way to classify foods?An international expert consensus judged GI valid and reproducible, and said low-GI diets should always be judged within an otherwise healthy diet (3)Expert consensus

One detail about that cohort analysis: its authors found that the benefit of a low-GI diet looked similar to the benefit of eating more fiber and whole grains (8). In practice, the two advice lines point to the same foods.

In people with type 2 diabetes specifically, a separate meta-analysis of randomized trials also found lower HbA1c and fasting glucose on low-GI diets (6). If you are managing diabetes, our diabetes diet guide covers the plate method and carbohydrate counting.

Building Meals Around Low-GI Foods

Flat lima beans in an orange basket surrounded by green bean podsSave
Photo: Beth Macdonald / Unsplash
  • Legumes: lentils, chickpeas, kidney beans and soya beans are among the lowest-GI foods in the tables (1)
  • Grains: barley, rolled oats and pasta cooked al dente rather than instant cereals and white bread
  • Fruit: apples and oranges, eaten whole rather than as juice
  • Dairy: milk and plain yogurt
  • Vegetables: most non-starchy vegetables contain little carbohydrate, so their effect on blood sugar is small

Fiber-rich foods overlap heavily with low-GI ones, so our list of high-fiber foods is a useful companion. Some older grains are worth a look too, such as sorghum.

The Limits of Eating by GI

  • GI ignores portion size. Watermelon scores 76, but a normal serving holds little carbohydrate; that is why glycemic load exists (1).
  • Low GI is not a health label. Chocolate scores around 40 in the tables (1). Experts say GI should complement other measures such as fiber and whole-grain content (3).
  • Values vary by product. Cereals, including whole-grain versions, show wide variation because manufacturing methods differ (2).
  • The strongest evidence is in diabetes. The long-term disease links come from observational cohorts, which an umbrella review rated very low to low certainty (9).

Who Benefits Most

The consensus panel considered low-GI and low-GL diets particularly important for people with insulin resistance (3), a state in which the body’s cells respond poorly to insulin and blood glucose stays higher (13). Our insulin resistance diet guide goes further, and these everyday habits cover the non-food side. For everyone else, low-GI choices fit comfortably inside a balanced diet.

If you take insulin or glucose-lowering medication, talk to your doctor before changing how much or what type of carbohydrate you eat.

Frequently Asked Questions

What counts as a low-glycemic food?
On the glucose scale, where pure glucose scores 100, foods with a glycemic index of 55 or less are classed as low GI and foods of 70 or more as high GI. Values in between are medium. Legumes, most fruits, dairy and pasta usually fall in the low range.

Is brown rice low glycemic?
Not quite. In the international GI tables, boiled brown rice scores 68, which is medium, while boiled white rice scores 73. Brown rice is the better choice, but barley at 28 is a genuinely low-GI grain.

Are all low-GI foods healthy?
No. Chocolate has a GI of about 40 and ice cream about 51, both in the low range. Experts recommend judging GI inside an otherwise healthy diet, alongside fiber and whole-grain content, not as a standalone score.

Does a low-glycemic diet help you lose weight?
Modestly. A meta-analysis of 101 studies found small but significant improvements in body weight and BMI, with larger effects when people lowered their dietary GI by 20 points or more.

What is the difference between glycemic index and glycemic load?
GI ranks how quickly the carbohydrate in a food raises blood sugar. Glycemic load also accounts for how much carbohydrate a normal serving contains: it is the available carbohydrate in the serving multiplied by the GI, divided by 100.

The Bottom Line

A low-glycemic diet swaps fast-acting carbohydrates for slower ones, such as legumes, barley, rolled oats and whole fruit. The best evidence is for blood sugar control in diabetes, where it produces small but real improvements. Effects on weight are modest. Use GI together with portion size and overall food quality, and remember that how a food is processed and cooked can matter as much as what it is.


This article is for informational purposes only and is not a substitute for professional medical advice. Talk with a doctor or registered dietitian before making significant changes to your diet, especially if you have diabetes or take glucose-lowering medication.


Low-Potassium Diet: Who Needs It and How It Works

Diabetes Diet: Plate Method, Carbs and the Evidence

Insulin Resistance Diet: What the Evidence Backs

High Fiber Foods List and How Much Fiber You Need

Balanced Diet Guide With the 5 Food Groups

How to Lower Blood Sugar Naturally: 8 Evidence-Based Habits

FODMAP Diet: The 3 Steps and the List Errors

Okra Water: What the Trials Actually Show

Sourdough Bread Benefits: What Holds Up

References

  1. 1Diabetes Care · PMCncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2584181
  2. 2Am J Clin Nutr · PubMedpubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/34258626
  3. 3Nutr Metab Cardiovasc Dis · PubMedpubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/26160327
  4. 4BMJ · PMCncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8336013
+ 9 more sources− Hide 9 sources
  1. 5Am J Clin Nutr · PubMedpubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/31374573
  2. 6Nutrients · PubMedpubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/29562676
  3. 7Obes Rev · PubMedpubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/30460737
  4. 8Lancet Diabetes Endocrinol · PubMedpubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/38272606
  5. 9Crit Rev Food Sci Nutr · PubMedpubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/33261511
  6. 10Br J Nutr · PMCncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4579564
  7. 11Nutrients · PMCncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7352659
  8. 12Nutrients · PMCncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6835480
  9. 13StatPearls · NCBI Bookshelfncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK507839